Dhumpan vs. Nebulizers – Ancient Smoke Therapy vs. Modern Inhalation
Dhumpan vs. Nebulizers – Ancient Smoke Therapy vs. Modern Inhalation
*Here we will discuss two different treatment namely dhumpan and stabilizer
For respiratory specific purpose only...
Why comparison matter ?
*My personal view*- comparison matter so that we can combine both our ancient knowledge & modern knowledge to brighten the healthy future...
1) Dhumpan
The knowledge about dhumpan is found in Charak Samhita...
Traditionally it was used to treat cough,astama, sinusitis (kapha disorders)
In today's world Ayurvedic Practitioners uses this knowledge to treat many problems as I discussed in my previous article.
Before start, I added here an expert Quote which was given by my teacher...
"Dhumpana cleanses prana vaha srotas (respiratory channels) but must be done under guidance to avoid smoke toxicity"
- Dr. Saheel Imandar
Yess!! you read Right!!
An expert presence is very important here...
So let's talk about specific herbs used to treat different respiratory conditions :
(Note: these herbs are presented here as traditional remedies not cures...All information here given for educational purpose only)
1) For Asthama and Wheezing
•Bharangi (Clerodendrum serratum)
•Haridra (Turmeric)
•Guggulu (Commiphora mukul)
2) For Chronic Cough & Bronchitis
•Vasa (Adhatoda vasica)
•Pippali (Piper longum)
•Tulsi (Ocimum sanctum)
3) For Sinusitis & Nasal Congestion
•Ajamoda (Trachyspermum ammi) .
•Yavani (Carom seeds)
•Neem (Azadirachta indica)
4) For Chronic Lung Weakness
(Post-TB, COPD, Weak Immunity)
•Ashwagandha (Withania somnifera)
• Pushkarmool (Inula racemosa)
• Yashtimadhu (Licorice)
5) For Chronic Lung Weakness
(Post-TB, COPD, Weak Immunity)
• Ashwagandha (Withania somnifera) .
•Pushkarmool (Inula racemosa)
•Yashtimadhu (Licorice)
*The smoke which is created here is taken into controlled doses (not deep in lungs) to avoid irritation.
Chalanges to Acceptance of dhumpan:
•Lack of Modern validation :
Due to limited study on medicinal efficiency
•Inhalation risks :
Potential respiratory irritation(even though it is natural)
• It is assumed as a folk medicine outside of asian region
2) Nebulizer
above image shows parts of modern nebulizer. It has strong clinical evidence and accepted widely.
Used for treating
1.Acute astama/COPD
2.Cough
3.cystic fibrosis
Some advantages of nebulizers
-Medically proven, fast relief
-Precise dosage control
-Essential for emergencies (asthma attacks)
-Easily available in hospitals
𝐓𝐲𝐩𝐞𝐬 𝐨𝐟 𝐍𝐞𝐛𝐮𝐥𝐢𝐳𝐞𝐫𝐬
1.Jet Nebulizer:
These Nebulizers deliver gas through pressurized stream of air down a narrow tube or channel and through a opening creates a jet.
Both adults and children can use jet nebulizer.
2.Ultrasonic Nebulizers:
Ultrasonic Nebulizers have some limitations compared to Jet Nebulizers.
Their cost is 4 to 5 times that of jet nebulizers
But more efficient than jet nebulizers.
3.Mesh Nebulizers :
It is more efficient than other nebulizers.
Fast,quick and portable.
Due to higher efficiency of mesh nebulizers the dosages of drug formulations need to be adjusted in order to prevent , adverse effects of overdose.
Key medicines in nebulizers :
1.Albuterol(emergency relief)
2.Budesonide (steroid)
3.Ipratropium bromide (Atrovent) etc.
Disadvantages of nebulizers :
1.continuous mist contact may cause fungal infection inside mouth
2.It requires proper maintenance and hygiene of machines to avoid contamination.
"Nebulizers are globally accepted by hospitals, doctor and WHO as a life saving tools"
Final conclusion :
* So from my view it depend on us...how we take them
*Dhumpan can't compete with nebulizers in case of emergency conditions
But it is suitable for long term health care.
*Consult a doctor before switching from nebulizers to herbal therapies....
More from AyurHealth
1)Dhumpan
Join the Conversation 🔗:
Learn more about #Ayurveda #DiabetesCare #NaturalHealing.
Follow @ayurhealth!
No comments: